â€œWhich microphone is better for me? The Shure SM58 or the Beta 58A?
Some people might be asking themselves this question. Even though both microphones are popular, they have distinct features that make them different from each other. The answer to this question will depend on your type of musician and your personal preferences.
Now let’s try to dissect Shure SM58 vs Beta 58A
The Shure SM58 and the Beta 58A are both popular dynamic microphones. They both have a cardioid pickup pattern that is great for live performances. Both mics are also known for having high durability and quality sound at an affordable price.
Before we get into the gritty details of the two mics, we should first take a look at their distinguishing features.
For a start, the Beta 58A has an extended frequency response. Its new B-series diaphragm is constructed with a newly redesigned material that helps reduce the presence of unwanted elements in sound waves and increase its bandwidth. This means that when you use these mics on instruments with different ranges of pitches, you will notice that you are able to hear more of them better than other microphones.
Shure SM58 on the other hand, has been known to have a natural sound as opposed to the Beta 58A, which some consider slightly brighter. Shure SM58 is probably one of the most popular dynamic microphones in the world and is still being used by many gigs and singers and is cheaper than Beta 58A. So if you are on a budget but still want a good dynamic microphone, you cannot go wrong with SM58.
The following points outline the major differences between these two common professional microphones:
Main Difference Between Sm58 and Beta 58A
1. Polar Pattern
The Shure SM58 is built with a cardioid polar pattern, while the Beta 58 has a super cardioid polar pattern. The difference in polar patterns ultimately affects which microphone would be more appropriate for certain applications (e.g., close-up vocals vs guitar amps).
Both mics are known for their sound quality, but the Beta 58A is better suited for vocals because of its super-cardioid polar pattern, whereas the SM58 is better suited for loud instruments.
3. Output level
The Beta 58A has a greater sensitivity and a 4dB hotter output than the SM58 because of its neodymium magnet.
4. Frequency range
The Beta 58 has a much higher frequency range (50Hz~16kHz) than the SM58 (50Hz~15kHz). This means that the Beta 58A will reproduce a greater range of tones and harmonics than the Shure SM58.
The Beta 58A is more expensive than the Shure SM58, however, this is due to the fact that it has a neodymium magnet and higher output level.
The Shure SM58 has a warmer, more bassy-sounding tone than the Beta 58A.
The Beta 58A has a greater attenuation capacity than the Shure SM58 because of its neodymium magnet. This means the Beta 58A will be more sensitive to picking up external noises than the SM58.
The Beta 58A is heavier than the Shure SM58.
9. Quality of feedback
The Beta 58A is more susceptible to feedback than the SM58 because of its neodymium magnet and the proximity between performer and microphone.
The Shure SM58 has a rubber shock mount, making it more durable, whereas the Beta 58A does not have one. This means that the Beta 58A is more prone to handling noise (e.g., bumps).
As the Beta 58A is made of a hardened grille, it is less prone to any damage than the SM58.
These are some common differences between Shure SM58 and Shure BETA 58A. Now let’s try to answer some frequently asked question:
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Shure SM58 and Beta 58A need phantom power?
As both of them are dynamic microphones, they both do not need phantom power.
Do Shure SM58 and Beta 58A need preamps?
Again, as both of them are dynamic microphones, they do not need a preamp. The sound quality won’t be good if you use external preamps on them.
What is the best position for a dynamic microphone like SM58 or Beta 58A?
For the Beta 58A, you need to get it as close to the instrument as possible. This is because the sound of the mic might not be good if it is too far from your instrument. On the other hand, for a better sound quality with Shure SM58, you need to position it approximately two inches away from your instrument.
Is Beta 58A better for vocals than Shure SM58?
As the Beta 58A is a supercardioid microphone, it is less prone to feedback than the SM58. Thus, it might be a better choice if you are looking for a good vocal mic.
Are both of them usable in front of an amplifier?
If you are recording vocals with Shure SM58, then it will give more bass and warmth. On the other hand, Beta 58A will give you more clarity and detail in your recording.
What is a Shure SM58 used for?
It is generally used for live performances and studio recording.
What is a Shure Beta 58A used for?
It is generally used for live performances. It is also great for recording vocals, guitars, and other instruments because of its supercardioid pattern. However, the Beta 58A is not good for close-up vocals because it might pick up unwanted noises that will cause more problems than any value gained by using it.
Why is Shure Beta 58A so popular?
The Shure Beta 58A is very popular because of its frequency response. Its bright upper end, midrange, and low-frequency performance make it good for vocals and instruments. It is also known for its durability, quality, less susceptibility to feedback, and ease of setup. The price for the SM58 and Beta 58A is nearly the same.
Is Shure SM58 good for podcasting?
Yes. It is one of the most recommended mics for podcasting because it is good at picking up both vocals and instruments. The SM58 is great for anyone looking to record a quiet voice or with other instruments because it provides excellent recording quality.
Are Beta 58A and Shure SM58 good for gaming?
Yes. They are also good for gaming, but you might have to get close to the sound source because you need not worry about feedback.
Which one is better for beginners?
If you are a beginner, in order to get the most out of your investment, it is better to go for the SM58. However, if you are looking for a recorded sound that you can use with other instruments, then it is recommended that you go for Beta 58A.
Does Shure SM58 need pop filter?
No. It is good even without a pop filter as long as you are in a clean area. However, most of the professional mics have pop filters for better sound quality.
How much does Shure Beta 58A weigh?
As for weight, the standard Beta 58A weighs 0.62 lbs. In case you are interested in an additional pop filter for your Beta 58A, it is going to add a little more weight as it weighs about an ounce.
Conclusion: Shure SM58 vs Beta 58A
The Shure SM58 and Beta 58A are great microphones for live performances. Both mics have similar frequency responses, meaning they work well for vocals and instruments.
So, if you are on a budget you can get SM58 as they are a bit cheaper. But as Beta 58A is kind of like an upgrade from SM58, you might want to go for Beta 58A as it offers better sound quality. Therefore, if you are looking for a mic that can be used at parties, shows, gigs and studios then Shure SM58 and Beta 58A are great options.